Something is Broken 4 comments


It is incarceration statistics time again and things have not improved in the US since we last visited this subject.
The rates are up:

Figures just released by the Bureau of Justice Statistics indicate that as of midyear 2003, there were nearly 2.1 million inmates in the nation�s prisons and jails, representing an increase of 2.9% over the previous twelve months.
This is a rate of 715 per 100,000 residents!!??
Who is the nearest competitor? It is Russia which jails 554 per 100,000 which is down from 690 per 100,000 in 1995.
How does the US compare to some other developed economies? It is not a pretty picture:
Rates of incarceration per 100,000 for other industrialized nations include Australia � 114, Canada — 116, England/Wales — 143, France — 95, Germany � 96, and Japan � 54.
Are you reading about uncontrolled lawlessness in any of these countries?
The numbers appear to support the points made by Zombyboy and the talking dog in the comments to this post that there is a large racist component in our existing drug laws:
One in eight (12.8%) black males aged 25-29 was in prison or jail at midyear 2002, as were 1 in 27(3.7%) Hispanic males and 1 in 63 (1.6%) white males in the same age group.
Things don’t look too good if you are a black male. And even worse if you are a black male drug user :
While African Americans constitute 13% of the nation�s monthly drug users, they represent 35% of those persons arrested for drug crime, 53% of drug convictions, and 58% of those in prison for drug offenses.
Who are the other 87% of drug users? No big surprise here: whites 72% of users, Hispanics 11% and others 4%.
To the folks that argue that the declining crime rates must be a result of the increased incarceration I say phooey. First, if this were the case then we should see declining admissions as well but, no, admissions are increasing. Second, we should be looking at these numbers and asking: Why do we need to jail so many at all? The real issue is that in the US, in the land of the free, some things are broken.
Societies that incarcerate this large a portion of their population need to do some serious self evaluation and reworking.
Governments that incarcerate this large a portion of their population need to be redesigned.
Via Talkleft and Let it Begin Here.


4 thoughts on “Something is Broken

  • Open Source Politics

    Around the OSP Blogs

    [Insert welcome message of you choice here. I’ve run out of ideas.] Fred Washington discusses various issues, including liberals and political discourse, and George Tenet’s resignation (post from 6/4). Steve at the Modulator talks about incarceration r…

  • Open Source Politics

    Around the OSP Blogs

    [Insert welcome message of you choice here. I’ve run out of ideas.] Fred Washington discusses various issues, including liberals and political discourse, and George Tenet’s resignation (post from 6/4). Steve at the Modulator talks about incarceration r…

  • Open Source Politics

    Around the OSP Blogs

    [Insert welcome message of you choice here. I’ve run out of ideas.] Fred Washington discusses various issues, including liberals and political discourse, and George Tenet’s resignation (post from 6/4). Steve at the Modulator talks about incarceration r…

Comments are closed.